Doorgaan naar de website
OCLC Support

Why do ebooks we own only show as held At Other Libraries Worldwide?

Symptom 
  • We have selected ebooks in Central Index collections but they do not display as held in WorldCat Discovery
  • Ebooks display as At Other Libraries Worldwide
  • Records from a database marked Treat as Held show At [my] Library in the search results list, but the detailed record shows At Other Libraries Worldwide
Applies to 
  • Collection Manager
  • OCLC Service Configuration
  • WorldCat Discovery
Answer

Ebooks selected in Central Index collections

Titles in Collection Manager that are part of a Central Index collection can only set holdings on OCLC numbers and ISSNs. Since Central Index ebooks use unique identifiers and ISBNs for identification, holdings cannot be set on these titles.

This means that using the Collection Manager > Institution Settings > WorldCat Holdings setting will not set holdings, and holdings will not automatically be set in Record Manager since the ebook does not have an OCLC number.

Because of this, when searching in WorldCat Discovery these types of ebooks will not return as held when scoped to a local institution. They will only appear when scoped to Libraries Worldwide.

Please note that when selecting titles in Collection Manager, if the title has an OCLC number associated with it, the title will also be discoverable in the WorldCat or worldcat.org database, and because it has an OCLC number, the record will show as held by your institution.

Databases marked Treat as Held with no knowledge base collection

Some Central Index databases have no matching collection in the WorldCat knowledge base. You can still mark these databases Treat as Held in OCLC Service Configuration > Metasearch Content > Default Databases and Licensed Content, but the setting behaves differently on the two WorldCat Discovery screens:

  • Search results list - Treat as Held is applied, and the record shows At [my] Library
  • Detailed record, including direct links to the record - only actual holdings are shown, and the record shows At Other Libraries Worldwide

Holdings on Central Index records can only be set through an OCLC number or ISSN match against a knowledge base collection. When a database has no knowledge base collection, there is nothing to match against, so the detailed record falls back to At Other Libraries Worldwide. This applies to every record from that database, not only to individual titles. It is expected behavior, not a defect.

Because the detailed record does not show your library as holding the item, users may be offered Request Item through Interlibrary Loan alongside the Access Online link, even though your library has online access.

Treat as Held does not set WorldCat holdings itself, and holdings cannot be set on Central Index records in Record Manager or with a custom collection in Collection Manager. To check whether a database has a knowledge base collection, see the Content in the WorldCat knowledge base column of the complete list of databases on Available collections and databases.

Additional information

Because of this, using some of the Database facets will not return the expected results when scoped to a local institution. An example of this would be if a library has selected an ebook in the Ebook Central Perpetual Titles collection (ProQuest), does a generic search in WorldCat Discovery that would include the ebook that has been selected, and then uses the Database facet to select ProQuest Ebook Central. No results will be returned unless the Held By Library is switched to searching Libraries Worldwide.

Page ID
49087